Recently I was re-watching the film
Hello Dolly! after hearing those great old Jerry Herman tunes in the film
Wall-E. For those unfamiliar, there was quite a hulabaloo when the young Barbra Streisand was cast in the role, whereas the stage version had been pretty much synonymous with Carol Channing. Despite that, we gays still love her, even if we recognize this was perhaps not her best (or most appropriate) role. But how to explain that? Why is it that the majority of gay men love Babs the way we do, and so many others?
Thus I think it's time to offer you, gentle reader, a primer for the pantheon of female icons that we gay folk adore so much. And because I love lists, I'm going to offer my top 10 icons, followed by a laundry list of honorable mentions. Also we'll look at a few potential icons of the future - who will be talking about 25 years now with a great sigh saying, "Oh, I remember when I first saw
Elizabeth in the theater. Now THAT was a great time in movies!"
First up, my top 10 list. These are
in no particular order, because no matter how I rank them, I will hear cries of sacrilege (probably even from myself).

1.
Judy GarlandHow does one explain the pull of Judy? I admit that I wasn't even that impressed with Judy in my nascent years as a gay collegiate. But there are several reasons to explain her appeal. First is that quintessential role as Dorothy in
The Wizard of Oz. Her experience reminds us of our own - lost in a world that is new and scary, wishing for the comforts of a home where you truly belong - if only you had some kind friends to lean on and show you the way. Also Judy has that cache of being a young child star at the time when movie musicals were becoming quite popular. When she exhorted us all to "Get Happy," we gladly obliged.
2.
Liza MinelliOne can hardly mention Judy without bringing up her daughter in the same breath. We admire the way she fought to step outside her mother's shadow, taking the musical stage by storm all on her own. She pushed buttons and sang of hot jazz in
Cabaret (making us forget that the role of Sally Bowles is supposed to be played by an Englishwoman). And of course she kept marrying men of our number, so she's practically a gay man already. Liza with a Z - that's her!

3.
Barbra Streisand*sigh* Oh, Babs. It's the voice. It's the nails. It's the Jewish girl from Flatbush who makes it on the Great White Way and wins an Oscar in her very first movie role. It's her unconventional choices in leading men that makes us realize all of us stand a chance. (Ryan O'Neal as sex symbol? Believe it.) And of course she's just so easy to impersonate - a godsend for the drag queens out there.
4.
CherFirst she declares herself a "Half-Breed," and we identify with the outsider who isn't loved. Then she wears ostentatious-yet-fabulous gowns by Bob Mackie. And then she proves that she can really act, too - "Snap out of it!" Once she went disco, all the gays were ready to dance along and toss our non-existent long hair. Whoooaaaa!!!
5.
MadonnaAlthough she's the youngest on this list, Madonna has done more in her half-century to win the hearts of the gays than most singers do in a lifetime. She has continually skewered social norms regarding sex and religion, and we appreciate it. She also knows how to construct
a lot of amazing dance tunes!
6.
Bette DavisWe love Bette for one simple reason - she was the first big-mouthed broad who brought the bitch every time she walked in a room. Only she could turn, "Poor Eve!" into a classic line.

7.
Joan CrawfordJoan was in some ways Bette's twin for bitchery, but she also brought the glamour and the drama. And of course we know that she was (mostly)
Mommie Dearest in real life, which makes her both cool and creepy.

8.
Audrey HepburnAudrey defined glamour of the era - she looked good in everything, and always had those big fabulous sunglasses! No one else before or sense has made a string of pearls and a long cigarette holder look so very elegant. Then she became a big-time humanitarian, and no one appreciates selfless acts to help the world's forgotten more than the gays.
9.
Donna SummerDonna was the queen of the disco, and we sure loved our disco. Why, exactly? Disco was the chance to show of your hottest threads while shaking your booty on a lighted dance floor. Gay, gay, gay!!!

10.
Bette MidlerHer history starting in the gay baths made Bette an instant gay icon for life - she entertained us first, and we've been loyal ever since. Yet we also would have adored her anyway for being loud and brassy with big bazooms. Once she made us weep with
Beaches, we have never been the same.
And that's the list! Now for a few honorable mentions, who are certainly gay icons for some, but have not perhaps reached the pinnacle of gay icon stature:
-
Dolly Parton - "It costs a lot of money to look this cheap."
-
Julie Andrews -
Sound of Music - love!
Victor/Victoria - gay friendly!
-
Patti Labelle - Soul sistah had the craziest hair of the 80's. And she likes to eat.
-
Marlene Dietrich - She's the woman who made androgyny edgy and fabulous. Madonna owes her a debt.
-
Elaine Stritch - Elaine made it OK to drink vodka and sing at the top of your lungs. Not that I ever do that.
-
Gloria Gaynor - "I Will Survive" has been our anthem for years - if only she had more hits...
-
Carol Channing - She's the smile that ate Broadway -
Hello, Dolly, indeed!
-
Carol Burnett - That
Gone With the Wind sketch was worth a lifetime of laughs.
-
Lucille Ball - The original (and perhaps greatest ever) comedienne. And who wouldn't want to marry a hot Cuban?
-
Mary Tyler Moore - When she threw her hat up into the Minneapolis sky, she signaled freedom - for all! (Or that's how I saw it.) Plus having a sassy Jewish neighbor was totally our life.
-
Whitney Houston - She...eee...eee....will always love uuuuuuuuus...or maybe crack. It's whack!
-
Reba McEntire - Short, spunky, redheads are always our best girlfriends. Plus, girl loves her costumes!
-
Diana Ross - She was so fabulous and controversial that they made a really, really good musical about her! (Even if she denies it.)
-
Katherine Hepburn - She really qualifies as more of a lesbian icon (the jaw, the pants, that red sweater), but we still think she was a strong woman, and we love that.
-
Judi Dench &
Helen Mirren - Tough British babes for the ages!
Finally, without further adieu, I propose the women with the greatest potential to become our great icons of the new century. Which of them will stand the test of time?
-
Jennifer Hudson - She's our new Diana Ross. But girl's got curves!
-
Kathy Griffin - She adores us, so how could we not return the love?
-
Margaret Cho - Ditto!
-
Kelly Clarkson -
American Idol no more - she is hot, hot, hot.
-
Beyonce' - We're crazy in love with her.
-
Cate Blanchett - One minute she's a British queen, the next she's clawing out the eyes of Judi Dench. Bold!
-
Tilda Swinton - Androgyny is hot again, and Tilda's at the forefront. A new Marlene in the making?
-
Meryl Streep - When she gets Oscar nomination #20, you know we're throwing a party.
-
Glenn Close - She was in
Sunset Boulevard on Broadway. She may actually BE a gay man!
OK, now's your time to let me have it - where did I go wrong? Whom did I forget? Whom I have shown too much love? (Yeah, right.) And who else will define the future of gay men's DVD and CD collections?